Maharashtra Crisis: Debunk the Speaker Or.. SC to Sibbal #SupremeCourt #LawChakra
Kapil Sibbal, representing the Uddhav side, essentially argued that the SC interpretation of 10th Schedule which allows the defection by majority has led to the fall of govt and will lead to bulk defection and future govt falls.
0:00 Introduction
0:35 Sibbal Calling out Shinde faction !
4:35 Who should get the Party Symbol & Positions ?
7:20 Sibbal Questions the Role of Speaker
10:26 Judge Raises that Parl has made the law SC Cant do Much
13:02 SC Judge: This Will take us No-Where
Patna High Court Karnataka High Court Live Stream.
#Patnahighcourt #SupremeCourtofIndia #Supremecourt
Books on Constitution:-
Tools Used for editing:-
For business Enquiries:- eqnuire@lawchakra.in
#SupremeCourt#Mussorrie #advocate #lawyer #legal #livehighcourt #indianlaw #law #live #court #argument #criminaljustice #guiltyminds #learnadvocacy #courtlive #justicelive #lawmotivation #beajudge #ias #judge #law #legal #patnahighcourt #justiceashutoshkumar #judiciary #motivation #learnlaw #IAS #supremecourtofindia #IPS #2022 #Patnahighcourtstream #orissahighcourt #SupremeCourt #Orissahighcourt#GujaratHighCourt
#Law #Chakra#JusticeAshutoshkumar
*This Video is strictly for Legal Awareness & Education Purpose only.📚
🙏 Follow us on twitter, Instagram and facebook.
@Lawchakra
👉Twitter
👉 Instagram.
📑*Fair Use Policy -*
Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.
Watch more new videos about Law | Synthesized by Mindovermetal English
Every political party shall have thier own constitution,which shall define the role & responsibility of every elected party member M P / MLA / other elected members and office bearers of the party and further it shall also define the legal owners of the party assets incase of any dispute including symbol.
Then on the basis of that constitution anti defection law or dissendent law or party symbol and assets shall be decided but not by election commission or speaker . It is purely an internal affairs of the political party concerned.
Switching to another party only be allowed when a member is re elected on his own capability not otherwise .
Exception shall be the independent candidate who wins election on his or her own capacity.
What is Congress O and Congress R/Congress I?
Poor case , poorer representation ! Salve will just tear arguments to threads .
An ordinary prudent man can easily understand clandestine arguments of sibbal. Why this lengthy arguments ..is waste of time..and hoodwinking the courts
Till bjp is in power no judiciary.e.c. cbi.e.d. can do anything impartially because all these organization are backboneless and corrupt.inefficient.biased
This issue similarly in parliament arises then what S.C. do?
Kapil is himself legislators
If Govt is not of BJP all okay CJI will not preside over
Indirectly Kapil says it CJI preside the assembly or parliament then will be ok if govt is of BJP
Kapil only can decide what's the right who is right
Kapil you very well know who is leader of congress
It will have great impact on Kapil advocacy
It was okay with Kapil Sibbal when a MP who became CM of Orissa and also voted against Vajpayee govt based on speakers decision of executive's morality. Then speaker was constitutional authority
Kapil sibbal type lawyer always waste the time of supreme court, no logic, no valid argument unable to understand why Honourable supreme court admit these kind of matters. Lot of other important issues are pending since very long.
Sibal trying to bully judiciary into believing what he says which is factually & morally wrong!! After all it’s Shiv Sena MLAs who need to decide who is their leader. Who is anyone else to decide who they want to follow as their leader?! Uddhav had lost confidence of his legislative members & wanted a change of leader.
It's strange that such person "Sibbel" is called pioneer in law field, court fixer make him in such position. He can't argue properly except saying "What to do" If he can't argue. Shame on him
In such cases where mandate was taken by saying we are yuti there should be law before election no matter with whom you participate but after election only &,only same thing that before election yuti or aghadi or whatever should be together otherwise it is clear cheating with voters and own party constitution.if there is something happens wrong with yuti who was elected and no one is ready to form government Election should be taken again.This is the main point of this case.Nor the bjp or never the shivsena has right to cheat with voters.shivsena constitution is fully against cong.mentality.they should have gone with cong.if they have faced election together in 2019.So clear law should be made for parties and individual.so no one can cheat people.Everything is happening in this case because shivsena went with congress.If shivsena never wanted to go with bjp then they should have to face election again in 2019,because ncp never supported bjp.That is why amendment should be done in constitution to avoid cheating with voter after polling,either party should go form government with whom they faced election or they can keep themselves away from government.Also there should be rule that who is going to become cm should be announced by party publicly and with mla who will face election there consent letters should be taken,so whatever happens after election it will be legal and horse auctions will be eliminated by making just some changes in constitution and it will help to voters.
सत्य दलील से पडे है I Constitutional Authority क्या सत्य से पड़े है ? क्या सत्य को साबित करने के लिए इतना discussion होना चाहिए ?
Sc judges are waiting for promotion,modi mercy,gov post.
कपिल सिब्बल द्वारा मूर्खता पूर्ण बहस।कोई भी समझ सकता है कि इसके दलील में दम नहीं और स्टाइल देखो जैसे बहुत बड़ी दलील दे रहा हो।इसी तरह यह व्यक्ति sc में हावी रहता था।एक भी केस ये जीतता नही है ये केवल कोर्ट मैनेज करता है जिसे ex CJI ने कहा था।
Classic example how some idiots like Sibal have hijacked Court system and SC is allowing the clown to wanted time when they are much pressing cases.
Parties have their constitution and they will manage their factions. What did party do to YSJagan? People with power (majority) decide the process. Once it works for the clown, once against. And he is allowed to come in front of SC.
The speakers office (a constitutional body) is with bias, the most of the elected members are with shinde but the cronies in rs and lc with uddhav, mylords kindly save the democracy and decide in uddhavs favour. Such an absurd argument yet SC is entertaining. Sibbal doesn't get paid for nothing. No matter however useless arguments he presents courts still listen to him for 2.5 days..
How are these Judges taking bullshit from Sibal?He is not allowing Milords to speak,arm twisting judges,he is cutting judges midway when they are talking,
What sort of democracy we are living in , no hope, politician will not bring /amend the laws for a proper functioning of democracy intentionally , SC does not want involve much , then who will . The great Indian public?
SYMBOL IS LOOSING…
The laypeople know that what Modi is doing is absolutely evil and unfair.
The judiciary should not be afraid of this evil man. We had the highest regard for the CJI. But the way this cast is going seems like the 7 bench judges are all favouring Modi. Please review all the happenings in the the state of Maharashtra. How Shinde & the BJP bought the 40 MLA's and we're flying from state to state. They were each paid 50 crores.
The party name and symbol belongs to Thakere. His father established the party. This auto-rickshaw wall stays in the party for 2 years and then the BJP stepped in and bought the brighter. This they destroyed the whole of India.
May God Almigjty give there judges wisdom how, to be honest and unfearful.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Save India from this dictator and destroying our nation.
BJP central govt more important than Kapil sibbal, Actually sibbal already winner as per Constitution but d hearing looks how to make d smooth unnatural judgement to Unconstitutional forming govt
Bench is bewildered
Kapil sibal is making understand the judges how 10th acedule n beside 19th schedule, a section of a party can betray own party n can claim to form govt n rule. Why judes not understanding or unnecessarily not understanding. Its ironical
They are having problem with Governor
Forget 10th schedule
And afterward
lordship forget constitution
Let's see it in Moral sense
This is happening at highest court argument
People get elected by using party funds, symbols and supporters. Then someone with money buys these elected politicians and overthrows the party leadership who gave them the support to get elected. If this is not stopped now no political party will survive only people with money power will rule the country and it will be death of democracy
Mr sibbal wants Supreme Court to do the work of speaker and the governor. Supreme Court should simply decide not to interfere as the Govt of Maharashtra is working smoothly.
Sinde government is illegal government, stage managed by BJP. Really sad situation. What kind of democracy we have ?
सिब्बल साहब इस conandrum को आखिर में जनता बड़ी आसानी से सुलझा लेगी। आप लोग constitutionality, legality, logic वगैरा मे उलझते और उलझाते रहिए।